1910: Ty Cobb vs Nap Lajoie
The Deadball era comes alive this week on The Baseball Book Club as John is joined by Justin Renaldi of Nostalgic Baseball Geezer to kick off a special four-part series: The DeadBall Files.
In this debut episode, the spotlight turns to the legendary and larger-than-life Old Hoss Radbourn—a workhorse pitcher whose feats feel almost mythical in today’s game. Just how dominant was Radbourn, and what made him such a defining figure of early baseball?
Plus, John and Leroy dig into one of the most bizarre and controversial moments in baseball history: the 1910 American League batting title race between Ty Cobb and Nap Lajoie. From questionable scorekeeping to eyebrow-raising bunt tactics, it’s a story that still sparks debate more than a century later.
It’s history, controversy, and Deadball drama—just the way you like it.